A request for review of a confined feeding operations of 120 dairy cows plus replacements proposal west of Ponoka is in the hands of the NRCB. A decision is expected in the next four to six weeks. Illustration from the NRCB files

Special review for confined feeding operation goes to NRCB

The request for 125 cow dairy operation west of Ponoka will wait 4 to 6 weeks for a decision

A request for confined feeding operations (CFO) in Ponoka County just west of the Town of Ponoka has gone to the Natural Resources Conservation Board (NRCB) for review.

A special request for review came from Marcel Wassink, the owner of Milk and Honey Dairy, after the initial request was turned down in November.

Milk and Honey Dairy initially submitted an application to the NRCB June 29, 2017 to construct a new confined feeding operation of 120 milking cows plus replacements. The proposal sought a dairy barn at 92m by 50m with a synthetic-lined liquid manure storage of 80m by 50m by 5m deep.

According to the NRCB the first denial was made due to the plan being inconsistent with Ponoka County’s Municipal Development Plan (MDP). There were also concerns from neighbours raised, plus some recommended conditions should an approval come subsequent to a special review.

From the county’s perspective, Tom Webber, assistant CAO, spoke with the NRCB officials. He pointed out that the MDP states large CFOs are inappropriate for this area. The policy also requests the NRCB not allow CFOs when they are within two miles of the towns of Rimbey and Ponoka; in this case, the Town of Ponoka is within that limit.

“Mr. Webber explained that this setback was included in the MDP to safeguard expected growth of the town over the next 20 years,” states the first review. “He also stated that the area will be zoned commercial highway development, and no residential zoning is planned for that area.”

The report refers to the town’s annexed land, plus the highway commercial development on the west side of the Highway2 and Highway 53 interchange.

The recommendations, if following approval from the special review, include a three season construction deadline rather than one, a post construction inspection and that manure should be applied to cultivated land by injection.

Concerns were expressed by Logan Kautz, Ryan and Ashley LaFontaine and William Toporowski the first time around and again during the more recent review hearing on Jan. 29.

Each party, including Wassink were able to provide submissions to the review hearing. The Town of Ponoka provided a written submission and NRCB stated the town was unable to attend the hearing.

From Wassink’s perspective, the NRCB is the organization that really has final say in CFOs and some of the county’s policies within its MDP are requests more than law.

“The NRCB has defined the required setback from many types of residences,” adds Wassink in a written submission. “These setbacks protect neighbouring landowners from the potential negative effects of a confined feeding operation.”

For the town, the two mile radius of exclusion is supported. “The Town of Ponoka is satisfied with the Ponoka County MDP that maintains a minimum two (2) mile separation distance for CFOs from the Town of Ponoka municipal boundary,” states the town letter. “It is recommended that the two (2) mile separation distance be maintained.”

As for the affected neighbours, Kautz and Toporowski wrote against the CFO proposal in both hearings.

At the Jan. 29 hearing Kautz submitted concerns about property values dropping with an operation of this size. He also points out that the area of land is not big enough. “It should be noted that 80 acres is not nearly enough for a homestead, barn, manure pit, hay storage and 120 cows plus replacements, which could end up being closer to the 200 mark at any given time.”

Toporowski requested that the NRCB support the county’s MDP and two mile limit. “In turn this will protect the surrounding wetlands and the groundwater. All this land drains into the Battle River.”

He reiterated concerns with the size of the operation and points out there are two other CFOs relatively close to the proposed site.

NRCB stated it will take about four to six weeks before a final decision is made on this review.

Just Posted

Ponoka Legion commemorates 100th anniversary of Armistice Day

Ponoka residents pack Legion hall during Remembrance Day

Ponoka Secondary Campus alumni provides example of how to remember those who were lost

School’s annual Remembrance Day ceremony focuses on 100th anniversary of WWI armistace

Students at St. Augustine honour fallen Ponoka soldiers

The school’s Remembrance Day ceremony recognized the sacrifices of past soldiers

No pumping into Gull Lake for 5 years due to carp concerns

Worries of carp in the Blindman River has put a hold on pumping water into Gull Lake

Rural crime task force results released at Agri-Trade luncheon

Report cites problems with police not being able to keep up with crime and justice system issues

Calgarians vote ‘no’ to bidding for 2026 Winter Games, in plebiscite

Out of 767,734 eligible voters, 304,774 voted and 171,750 said ”no.”

Canada Post strike having ‘critical’ impact on retailers, eBay tells PM

Canada Post says it is now facing an unprecedented backlog of shipments, largely as a result of strikes

NASA wants Canadian boots on the moon as first step in deep space exploration

The U.S. is seeking broad international support for the next-generation space station to send into orbit a in 2021

B.C. man wanted in connection to domestic assault in Edmonton

Sterling Miles Booker has ‘ROCK’ and ‘ROLL’ tattooed on his hands

Canada wants free trade deal with southeast Asian nations, Trudeau says

ASEAN nations combined have nearly 650 million people, an economy of US$2.8 trillion, and are already Canada’s sixth-biggest trading partner.

Olympic and Paralympic committees disappointed, but respectful of Calgary’s vote

The majority of voters said ‘no’ to a potential Calgary bid for the 2026 Winter Olympics and Paralympic Games.

Wildfire death toll rises in California as search for missing continues

Authorities reported six more fatalities from the Northern California blaze, bringing the total number of dead so far to 48.

B.C. MLAs urge Trudeau to call byelection immediately in Burnaby-South

Four NDP provincial politicians from British Columbia are urging Prime Minister Justin Trudeau to immediately call a byelection in the federal riding of Burnaby-South.

Prince Charles turns 70 with party, new family photos

Charles is due to have tea on Wednesday with a group of people who are also turning 70 this year

Most Read