With the Town of Ponoka entered into a public private partnership to develop the new town hall, some residents are concerned with the long term payments and interest that comes with them. File photo

There are pros and cons to public private partnerships

With Ponoka entering into a lease with a private company, some residents are still concerned

With the Town of Ponoka’s new town hall under way, there are still some concerns around the terms of the agreement.

Council voted in favour of the lease agreement — which sees a public private partnership (P3) with developer Landrex — stating a focus on seeing new development in town. Where some took issue is the lease rates that would see the company receive about a 10 per cent return on investment.

That, compared to a two to three per cent interest rate with the Alberta Capital Finance Authority if the town constructed the building on its own, was part of the worry. Mayor Rick Bonnett, however, has been vocal about his support for the P3, stating other large capital projects such as a new RCMP building and a new field house will also have to be paid for.

The lease caused enough concern that resident Greg Nelson served the town notice, seeking to have councillors personally liable for the borrowing bylaw. It was determined that the building didn’t exceed the town’s borrowing due it being a lease with the town able to borrow $16 million and the building costing $9 million.

That’s where Ponoka County resident Nick Kohlman, and town resident Edwin Geuder voiced worry.

They have two major concerns. First, the long term cost of the lease to taxpayers should the town not exercise its buyout option; the second being that the length of the lease appears to show a much larger amount of money being spent.

“The cost of the learning centre lease according to the town’s auditor, with average inflation, is an estimated $22.8 million, plus a $2.4 million town cost for interior construction, for a total of about $25.2 million,” states a letter from Geuder and Kohlman.

They feel it’s an unresolved borrowing amount, it’s confusing for residents, and they would like to see the bylaw changed to clarify the lease amount against the cost of the building.

The value of the new town hall, at the time of the lease, was not indicated and was not included in the bylaw — which was something Justice Kevin Feehan in the court proceedings with the town was concerned about. Feehan even suggested the town amend its bylaw, which would create a public hearing process.

Council has not amended the bylaw, and that may not occur. This late into the construction of the new town hall, a successful petition against the amendments could cause a delay of construction and potentially legal issues.

“It is the borrowing bylaw that authorizes the expenditure for the lease. There is no indication in the bylaw to suggest that the borrowing is only $9 million,” states the letter.

Geuder and Kohlman argue that the lease exceeds the town’s borrowing, which makes councillors liable. That wasn’t the decision by Justice Feehan, however, he stated the law in the Municipal Government Act (MGA) regarding leases for capital projects in unclear.

Municipalities using PPPs

In an interview with Dr. Karim Jamal, department chairperson of University of Alberta’s accounting, operations and information systems, these P3s are usually done by municipalities looking to work with capital projects where they may not have enough to debenture.

“In this (Ponoka’s) case it appears more to be a foolish decision than anything else,” stated Jamal, who feels the town would have been better off doing the project on its own.

These types of long term leases are not new, and the MGA does not specifically address P3s. With international accounting standards, Jamal says leases such as these are not really part of determining debt. Municipalities and corporations have used this to some degree.

“It’s kind of a loophole effectively,” said Jamal.

“You kind of borrow in a way but it doesn’t get counted as a borrowing…you’re kind of relaxing the limit.”

The borrowing rate is unclear, something that Geuder and Kohlman point out in Ponoka’s case. Jamal calls it a legal manoeuvre.

“Once you sign the lease, effectively you’ve bought the building. You’re just not calling it a purchase, it’s just a lease,” explained Jamal.

Companies can move the debt within the same balance sheet because it’s a lease. But that’s changing.

“I think at the end of this year there’s a new lease standard change,” he explained.

One more project like the new town hall and Ponoka would have been over its borrowing limit, said Jamal, pointing out that the town is indeed within its borrowing limits.

When asked why the province allows P3s to occur, Jamal suggested planners may not have realized there was a loophole in accounting.

Just Posted

Rabbits saved from barn fire in Ponoka County

The Ponoka County East District Fire Department was called to a barn fire

Bashaw peewee club’s season comes to an abrupt end

Players decide not to go into playoffs without one of their teammates

Ponoka man attacked by dogs issues plea to town council

Troubles with bylaw and handling of court case prompts presentation to council

Concerns over town expressed to Ponoka County council

Resident warns county council in collaboration discussions with Town of Ponoka, council notes its own concerns

Ponoka County resident wants $62,000 in lease revenue

County approves revenue to landowner going forward, legal review to look at retroactive funds

Sylvan Lake’s Megan Cressey misses Freestyle Skiing Big Air podium

Alberta’s Jake Sandstorm captured silver in the men Freestyle Skiing Big Air contest

Why do zebras have stripes? Perhaps to dazzle away flies

Researchers from University of Bristol look into why zebras have stripes

Poll: More voters believe Canada doing worse under Trudeau government

22 per cent believed the country is doing better and 27 per cent said things are the same

Ponoka host to Bayer Crop Science seed innovations trade show

The company held a trade show with seed crop science industry partners at the ag event centre

Peter Tork, Monkees’ lovable bass-guitar player, dies at 77

Tork, Micky Dolenz, David Jones and Michael Nesmith formed the made-for-television rock band

Lacombe welcomes ‘Napalm Girl’ to discuss journey from hatred to forgiveness

Latest Herr Lecture to feature Kim Phuc Phan Thi at LMC

Millennial men least likely to have a family doctor: Statistics Canada

Report found more women have primary care physicians, compared with men

Alberta to play for gold in wheelchair basketball

Action-packed first week of Canada Winter Games nearly a wrap

Most Read