Fine line between security and civil rights

I would like to respond to Gord Gramlick’s letter published in the Ponoka News on the 9th of October.

Dear Editor,

I would like to respond to Gord Gramlick’s letter published in the Ponoka News on the 9th of October.

Though secrecy in Canada’s security agencies is important, the downside is that those who are detained often do not have access to the reasons for their detention. Evidence against them is not shared with either the detainees or their lawyers. There is no mechanism for which this evidence at present can be declassified.

Mohamed Harat, for instance, was detained in 2002 under these provisions and was only set free in 2006. His lawyers are currently challenging his detention in the Supreme Court, supported by the Canadian Bar Association, the Canadian Council of Criminal defence lawyers and Amnesty International.

John Adams, the former chief of Communications Security Establishment Canada (CSEC), believes that the federal government needs to do more to demonstrate to Canadians that CESC “ is protecting national security while respecting civil liberties”. He says that as CSEC chief “when parliamentarians would raise concerns”, he could not address these concerns “because they weren’t cleared to receive classified information.”

He recommends an intelligence and security committee, as in the U.K. composed of parliamentarians and senators that would keep tabs on the conduct of security agencies. They would be cleared at the highest security levels, sworn to secrecy, and could debate, as a committee, issues of concern.

There is a sometimes a fine balance between secrecy and the protection of civil rights. Hopefully some of this will be clarified in the upcoming Supreme Court decision involving Mr. Harat.

George Jason.


Just Posted

PHOTOS: Ice racing at Mulhurst Bay at Pigeon Lake

Results of the ice racing event at Pigeon Lake

Maskwacis RCMP lay charges from home invasion

Four charged in alleged invasion using knives and gun on Samson Cree Nation - three injured

UPDATE: Highway 2 lanes were closed due to milk truck fire near Millet

A southbound truck hauling milk and cartons collided with a bridge

Ponoka Airport taxiway improvement costs overrun

The $328,000 project increased to $359,000, gravel cited as main reason for the increase

Ponoka County council looks at how it sees collaboration

County wants separate negotiations with Ponoka, Rimbey

WATCH: Ponoka residents enjoy first skate on ice path

A community initiative helped create a skate path for families in Ponoka.

Suspected Toronto serial killer targeting gay community arrested

A 66-year-old man is charged with first-degree murder in disappearance of two Toronto men

Barenaked Ladies, Steven Page, to be inducted into Canadian Music Hall of Fame

Canadian band to get top honours at 2018 JUNO Awards

B.C. out of the running for Amazon’s next headquarters

Toronto is the only Canadian city left in the running despite the province backing Metro Vancouver’s bid for new Amazon headquarters

Post interest rate hike debt tips

What to do about your debt and mortgages after the interest rate hike

Foreign workers sleeping in Alberta Burger King basement

Alberta Health Services said its inspectors found foreign workers sleeping in the basement of the Lethbridge restaurant

Court application halts release of bread price-fixing documents

Bread price-fixing documents won’t be unsealed Thursday, Loblaw says

Pharrell and N.E.R.D to headline NBA All-Star halftime show

11-time Grammy winner Pharrell and his hip hop-rock band N.E.R.D. will headline the halftime show at the 2018 NBA All-Star game in Los Angeles

Heritage Minister wants zero tolerance for harassment in entertainment industry

Heritage Minister Melanie Joly had two meetings to discuss harassment in the film, TV and theatre worlds

Most Read