Fracking debates alienate

If you imagine the future, what does it look like? Is the future you see dependent on oil?

Dear Editor:

If you imagine the future, what does it look like? Is the future you see dependent on oil? Some say we’ve lived for millennia without it, surely we can live without again.

In learning about the peak oil crisis, I have heard many people ask, “Does it mean we all need to be farmers?” I don’t think so. Rather, I think it means that we begin taking back responsibility over our own lives and our own communities.

What are the things that we are “response-able” for? Are we responsible for the clothes we wear? The food we eat? How important is it to be responsible for these things?

Erich Fromm wrote of pre-Second World War German society as a people free from belonging to a social order. He believed it was because Germans were not accountable to each other that so many submitted to an authority. That next authority was the Nazi regime. Fromm’s observation warns us that if we are not responsible for the wellbeing of our neighbour, our “freedom” from belonging to each other will overwhelm us and we will submit to the next authority.

At what risk?

Do you live in a free-from-belonging society? What is the authority to which we now submit? What would your life look like if you took responsibility for your neighbour, perhaps a stranger? What if they did the same for you? Now, what does your future look like?

The topic of hydraulic fracturing is an increasingly controversial subject. Why? Perhaps because it is both a water and a livelihood issue. Many Albertans work in the oil and gas industry; it is how they support their families. So, arguments against the industry are personal because one’s livelihood — and the livelihood of one’s children — seem at stake. Yet, there are also many Albertans who have been dehumanized by this same industry. Their stories are chilling — of burned skin, methane water, sickly animals, sickly children. Naturally, these Albertans want to see a change, if not a moratorium, on the process of fracking. Others sit somewhere in the middle, uncertain between which side is “right”. Most haven’t even heard about the process. The fracking issue pits livelihood against livelihood. It is no surprise that these “sides” are so alienated from each other.

So where do we go from here? How do we speak to each other when one is so hurt and when another must risk “everything?”

We create a space where all sides simply share a meal and their stories. Even in this issue, in this province, the commonalities between our stories far outweigh the differences. When we listen to our neighbour’s story, we begin to be responsible for their wellbeing. And when do this, we begin to have the future for which we all hope.

On Nov. 2 and 3, the Augustana Campus of the University of Alberta hosts this common space. Please join us and register at

“Will we get the future we plan for?” I don’t know, will you?

Carmelle J Mohr

Just Posted

Wolf Creek Schools raises Treaty 6 flag for first time

Chiefs, school officials took part in a ceremony that is aimed at acknowledging Treaty 6 land

Pair arrested in Ponoka with several weapons, face 98 charges

Two men nabbed after early morning suspicious vehicle reported, stolen weapons found

UPDATE: 18-year-old Rimbey teen dies in collision

A portion of Highway 53 west of Rimbey is down to one lane while crews investigate

Ponoka County approves $70,000 to dredge Parkland Beach

Parkland Beach to see some dredging support from Ponoka County

Ponoka sets bylaw on cannabis retail, pushes for quick public consumption regulation

Town passes first reading on retail outlet bylaw, questions staff on need to separate public usage

U.S. congressman issues dire warning to Canada’s NAFTA team: time is running out

Canadian Foreign Affairs Minister Chrystia Freeland is expected to resume talks with the U.S.

Update: Search called off for missing plane between Edmonton and Chilliwack

Search efforts were concentrated along the Highway 5 corridor between Valemount and Kamloops

Canada signs global pact to help rid world’s oceans of abandoned fishing gear

The federal Fisheries Minister says it’s a ‘critical issue’

GOP pushing forward for Kavanaugh, accuser wants ‘fairness’

Kavanaugh has denied al allegations of sexual misconduct

Rural Canada Post carriers could see 25-per-cent pay hike: spokesman

An arbitrator has released a ruling in a long-standing pay equity dispute at Canada Post

Freeland brings optimism back to NAFTA talks

NAFTA talks resume in Washington

Bradley Williams takes over as Westerner Park Interim CEO

CFR expected to go on as scheduled with no disruption

Despite protests, Russia’s anti-doping agency reinstated

On a 9-2 vote, the executive committee declared RUSADA as having satisfied conditions

The longest week: Carolinas worn out by Florence

Frustration and sheer exhaustion are building as thousands of people wait to go home seven days after the storm began battering the coast.

Most Read