Hard for councils to be right and popular – Editorial

GEORGE BROWN / Off the Record

Messy business, this democracy thing.

At all levels, the fundamentals of democracy are visible and at play in Alberta today. From the health care debate in Alberta that is being driven by patients and their doctors, to the federal election call that was precipitated by a contempt of Parliament declaration by the Opposition, to businesspeople in Rimbey fighting town hall over removal of tax incentives, democracy is alive and well, if not a little battered.

It’s certainly easy for governments to make policy and enact laws but the real test of a government’s mettle is in defending those decisions to a gallery of iratepayers who come out of the woodwork when those decisions are considered to threaten their pocketbook or their enjoyment of the community.

In Ponoka, that means pilots and residents who don’t want a stand of trees FernGullyed without assurances the removal of the trees is absolutely necessary to fulfill a master plan for specific airport improvements that would benefit the community. But there was no plan, there is still no plan and there is no funding this year even if there were a plan.

At least twice, a delegation concerned enough about their community to attend a town council meeting was all but ignored by the mayor. In a democracy, you sometimes have to look your citizens in the eye when they disagree with you.

Council is also involved in a generational confrontation with residents of 38th Street over alleged irregularities in utilities projects and the costs of a local improvement charged to property owners. Nothing short of a judicial determination will satisfy this committee of residents who aggravate council. While the mayor, council and administration feel they have answered the residents’ question to the best of their ability, the same questions are now asked by the same people to a group of rookie councillors — the majority of whom live on 38th Street. FOIP issues prevent council from being forthright with these residents and three of the new councillors feel they are in conflict of interest if they participate in resolving this matter.

While councillors should demand a certain civility from delegations in the council chambers, it was somewhat outrageous for the mayor to threaten to sue his citizens whose statements during a council meeting, no matter how erroneous or defamatory, are protected by qualified privilege, the same as his. Empires have crumbled for lesser reasons.

Meanwhile at the west end of the county…

Ponoka town council is not alone in engaging its citizenry in battle. In Rimbey, council has moved to balance its budget by repealing a now controversial tax incentive bylaw.

The affected businesses in Rimbey don’t care town council is doing what it feels is necessary to repeal a bylaw believed to be ultra vires. It’s likely that most residents and businesspeople who did not benefit from the tax incentives were not aware council had such a bylaw on the books. It’s not a policy that was trumpeted annually, it was a carrot administration and the town’s economic development promoters would have dangled to encourage new businesses to establish in Rimbey or to coax existing businesses to expand or renovate — and in the end add valued assessment to the tax pool.

It might have been an easier bylaw to carry on the books during the boom when hotels, restaurants and new homes were springing up but today, when council is not blessed with huge year-over-year assessment increase to offset expenditures, removing tax breaks is a relative, if not short-sighted, no-brainer.

Certainly the previous council and town manager believed they were providing a legal incentive to businesses in the hopes of providing jobs and creating new assessment.

That two law firms would disagree on whether the practice is illegal is not at all surprising. If a majority of councillors felt they had an option the practice of granting tax incentives could be supported by a learned legal opinion. That lawyers disagree is not surprising; there aren’t many billable hours in presenting an opinion that agrees with another lawyer.

If councillors feel it is in the best interests of the community to continue with some form of tax incentive, their creativity can make it happen.

Rimbey is not going to become a ghost town because the tax holiday is cancelled but if businesspeople have to pay thousands of dollars more in taxes over the next few years, it will certainly see fewer employment opportunities, reduced sponsorship of community events and sports teams, stalled expansion, and the relocation of some businesses to the rural area or back into residential basements.

If the tax incentive is indeed illegal and council needs to repeal the bylaw, then it needs to be fair in dealing with these business owners. A phased approach to cancellation or at least a year’s notice would seem to be in order. These businesses would have budgeted for the lower tax rate and to take it away without notice is irresponsible. That’s not to say residential taxes need to rise correspondingly; this is a burden that bust be carried on the commercial mill rate.

Council should have advised the business community of its intention before moving to cut the tax incentive and now they must endure the criticism and listen to the options that will be presented to them. If nothing else, council must give the appearance of listening to its constituents.

It can’t expect to be both right and popular in the community.

Just Posted

Ponoka’s Ronnie Racing wins Hot August Night

About 15,000 people filled the Castrol Raceway stands at the motorsports complex

Ponoka County residents divided on farmland uses

There were about 150 people at the county’s meeting related to reducing confined feeding operations.

Ponoka County slows changes to CFO plans

Residents speak their concerns over the potential of changing areas allowing CFOs

PHOTOS: Samson Cree Nation Pow Wow

The Samson Cree Nation hosted its annual Pow Wow, celebrating youth this year

Ponoka Traffic Unit investigate scooter incident

A motorcyclist appears to have lost control of her Suzuki scooter on Highway 2 north of Ponoka

‘We will not forget:’ Thousands attend funeral fallen Fredericton officers

Hundreds of officials marched in the parade, which included massed band, several police motorcycles

WATCH: Pioneer Days runs all weekend at Sunnybrook Farm

Red Deerians brave the smoke to celebrate Sunybrook’s biggest event

Ride to Reynolds Alberta Museum in Wetaskiwin

Smoky but awesome event celebrates everything ‘motorcycles;’ open Sat. Aug. 18 to 4 p.m.

Canadians believe in immigration but concerned about asylum seekers: study

Immigration, Refugees and Citizenship Canada paid for study to understand Canadian attitudes

These are the highest-paid actresses of 2018

In its list released this week Forbes said all 10 earned a total of $186 million before tax

Vintage vehicle subject of RCMP search

Two Hills RCMP seek to identify owner of recovered 1940’s vehicle

Canada’s tax system unfairly favours wealthy, poll of CRA auditors suggests

Four of every five respondents think loopholes and tax credits built into the system benefit the rich

Banff’s Sunshine ski resort upset with proposed guidelines from Parks Canada

The plan would allow for more visitors but wouldn’t let Sunshine build additional facilities

Publication ban lifted on details about Fredericton shooting that killed 4

Judge lifts publication ban on court documents related to the Fredericton shooting

Most Read