LETTER: Alberta’s schools are funded by all taxpayers

A Ponoka News reader responds to the web poll results story related to separate school systems

Dear Editor,

Re: Your June 11/2018 article (web poll results printed June 13) on separate school “choice”.

The discussion of whether “separate” schools should receive taxpayer funding has been distorted by the misleading fallacy that religious schools are funded only by those who choose them. In Alberta, religious schools are funded by all taxpayers, including those who do not choose them.

Red Deer, where I live, no longer wastes ink on its property tax form with a phoney but meaningless option to support either the “public” or “separate” school system. Both systems receive exactly the same per-student provincial funding as before when the discontinued but deceptive option was still used.

Property tax revenues do not come close to funding Alberta’s public and separate schools. The shortfall is made up from general revenues, expanding the inroad of religious school funding beyond property taxes. So, too, with the so-called “private” schools that, despite their name, receive 70 per cent public support.

Maintaining two comparable, taxpayer-funded school systems with identical functions is costly. In September, 2017 Alberta Views magazine reported that, beyond the cost of instructing students, in 2015-2016 “Catholic boards in Alberta spent $229-million on operations and maintenance, $64-million on transportation and $59-million on administration. Much of these costs would be eliminated in a single system … .” How many more teachers and what program and facility improvements could Alberta afford if not burdened with two parallel systems?

Canada rightly prides itself on personal freedom. Some wrongly confuse their right to school choice with entitlement to taxpayer funding of their personal choice. Coercing people through the tax system to pay for other people’s personal religious choices necessarily violates their religious freedom to believe and act as they choose. Whether through the Catholic system, so-called private schools, or religiously oriented alternative programs in public schools, public funding of religious schools unquestionably violates the Charter-protected religious freedom of those who are coerced to pay for other people’s choices. No one’s religious freedom outweighs the religious freedom of anyone else.

William Weiswasser

Red Deer

Just Posted

Speed zone changes hoped for at three entrances to Ponoka

Council makes several requests of Alberta Transportation regarding highway speeds

Ponoka offering up leftover fire inventory to Ponoka County

Trucks already sold by town, remaining equipment to be sold or donated

Ponoka mayor denies allegations of conflict

A Ponoka resident maintains Mayor Rick Bonnett has taken work on the new town hall

Ponoka runners complete gruelling 100 mile Sinister 7 ultra

One team hit second place, another 95th, while a solo runner landed in the 24th spot

Woman jumps in front of semi on Highway 2

Potentially tragic event averted on QEII with help of Ponoka ITU members

WATCH: Lightning over Ponoka

A Ponoka News reader sent us this short video of the lightning early Wednesday morning over Ponoka

WATCH: Red Deer’s Westerner Days kicks off to a smoking hot start

Thousands take in the food, entertainment, rides and more at Westerner Park

Two charged near Sundre after dog, cat, horse and five lambs stolen

Witnesses give valuable information to police, stolen property recovered

Parks Canada looks to shine light on cloudy future for historic sites

A plan is in place to produce 10-year plans designed to turn around sagging attendance figures

Ontario police say attack on Muslim man was motivated by hate

Two men, aged 27 and 19, have been charged with assault in the incident

Price no guarantee for safety with horse riding helmets: new report

A Swedish insurance report reveals that many brands of equestrian helmets do not protect riders as well as they could.

Red Deer RCMP investigate $26,000 tool theft

Suspects seen heading north toward Queen’s Industrial Park

Innisfail RCMP seize eight dogs from hotel room following earlier arrest

Dogs were in distress and taken to an animal rescue organization

VIDEO: Toronto Raptors send DeMar DeRozan to Spurs in colossal NBA trade

Toronto also sent Jakob Poeltl and 2019 first-round pick, gets Kawhi Leonard and Danny Green

Most Read