Letter: Don’t fall for smoke and mirrors related to dairy supply

A Ponoka News reader speaks to a recent story on the question of Canada’s dairy supply management

Dear Editor,

Response to: Research paper states low income earners hit hardest by dairy supply management.

There are so many holes in this research it looks a lot like swiss cheese to me.

The concept that lower income earners will always have a higher percentage of their income go towards consumer goods and services compared to a higher income is obvious. This theory can be used for toilet paper to cars as well and does not simply apply to dairy. So it’s important to not get caught up in the smoke and mirrors of this headline: Supply management works for Canadians.

One does not need to look far other than AC Nielson, the gold standards for consumer prices, to identify that dairy prices in Canada are in fact lower than in the USA. For example, the cost of one litre of milk in Canada is $1.51 and in the USA it’s $1.61. This compares the synthetic hormone-free varieties in the USA as it’s illegal in our Canadian cows.

This isn’t an anomaly. The prices in deregulated markets have in fact increased in countries like Australia, thus costing the lower income earners a higher percentage of their income.

And let’s be clear: supply management isn’t a tax of any sort. In fact, the USA’s open market system will hit their wallets a lot more than ours. Tax payers pay $22.2 billion of their tax dollars to subsidize their dairy farms. So they pay twice. Canadians pay once at the till and those tax dollars go towards schools, roads and infrastructure.

This story also doesn’t show the entire picture. It ignores the desperate state of the dairy industries in deregulated countries. American dairy farmers are struggling to make a living and many states are seeking a supply managed model as a solution.

Tom Kootstra, local dairy farmer and chairman of Alberta Milk

Just Posted

Rabbits saved from barn fire in Ponoka County

The Ponoka County East District Fire Department was called to a barn fire

Bashaw peewee club’s season comes to an abrupt end

Players decide not to go into playoffs without one of their teammates

Ponoka man attacked by dogs issues plea to town council

Troubles with bylaw and handling of court case prompts presentation to council

Concerns over town expressed to Ponoka County council

Resident warns county council in collaboration discussions with Town of Ponoka, council notes its own concerns

Ponoka County resident wants $62,000 in lease revenue

County approves revenue to landowner going forward, legal review to look at retroactive funds

Sylvan Lake’s Megan Cressey misses Freestyle Skiing Big Air podium

Alberta’s Jake Sandstorm captured silver in the men Freestyle Skiing Big Air contest

Why do zebras have stripes? Perhaps to dazzle away flies

Researchers from University of Bristol look into why zebras have stripes

Poll: More voters believe Canada doing worse under Trudeau government

22 per cent believed the country is doing better and 27 per cent said things are the same

Ponoka host to Bayer Crop Science seed innovations trade show

The company held a trade show with seed crop science industry partners at the ag event centre

Peter Tork, Monkees’ lovable bass-guitar player, dies at 77

Tork, Micky Dolenz, David Jones and Michael Nesmith formed the made-for-television rock band

Lacombe welcomes ‘Napalm Girl’ to discuss journey from hatred to forgiveness

Latest Herr Lecture to feature Kim Phuc Phan Thi at LMC

Millennial men least likely to have a family doctor: Statistics Canada

Report found more women have primary care physicians, compared with men

Alberta to play for gold in wheelchair basketball

Action-packed first week of Canada Winter Games nearly a wrap

Most Read