Letter: Don’t fall for smoke and mirrors related to dairy supply

A Ponoka News reader speaks to a recent story on the question of Canada’s dairy supply management

Dear Editor,

Response to: Research paper states low income earners hit hardest by dairy supply management.

There are so many holes in this research it looks a lot like swiss cheese to me.

The concept that lower income earners will always have a higher percentage of their income go towards consumer goods and services compared to a higher income is obvious. This theory can be used for toilet paper to cars as well and does not simply apply to dairy. So it’s important to not get caught up in the smoke and mirrors of this headline: Supply management works for Canadians.

One does not need to look far other than AC Nielson, the gold standards for consumer prices, to identify that dairy prices in Canada are in fact lower than in the USA. For example, the cost of one litre of milk in Canada is $1.51 and in the USA it’s $1.61. This compares the synthetic hormone-free varieties in the USA as it’s illegal in our Canadian cows.

This isn’t an anomaly. The prices in deregulated markets have in fact increased in countries like Australia, thus costing the lower income earners a higher percentage of their income.

And let’s be clear: supply management isn’t a tax of any sort. In fact, the USA’s open market system will hit their wallets a lot more than ours. Tax payers pay $22.2 billion of their tax dollars to subsidize their dairy farms. So they pay twice. Canadians pay once at the till and those tax dollars go towards schools, roads and infrastructure.

This story also doesn’t show the entire picture. It ignores the desperate state of the dairy industries in deregulated countries. American dairy farmers are struggling to make a living and many states are seeking a supply managed model as a solution.

Tom Kootstra, local dairy farmer and chairman of Alberta Milk

Just Posted

Speed zone changes hoped for at three entrances to Ponoka

Council makes several requests of Alberta Transportation regarding highway speeds

Ponoka offering up leftover fire inventory to Ponoka County

Trucks already sold by town, remaining equipment to be sold or donated

Ponoka mayor denies allegations of conflict

A Ponoka resident maintains Mayor Rick Bonnett has taken work on the new town hall

Ponoka runners complete gruelling 100 mile Sinister 7 ultra

One team hit second place, another 95th, while a solo runner landed in the 24th spot

Woman jumps in front of semi on Highway 2

Potentially tragic event averted on QEII with help of Ponoka ITU members

Trudeau asks transport minister to tackle Greyhound’s western pullout

Prime Minister Justin Trudeau says he’s asked Transport Minister Marc Garneau to find solutions in Greyhound Canada’s absence.

Restaurant Brands International to review policy over poaching employees

One of Canada’s largest fast-food company to review ‘no-poach’ franchise agreements

Calgary family’s vacation ends in tragedy on Texas highway

Three people died and four others were injured in the crash

Trudeau to shuffle cabinet ahead of Liberals’ team for 2019

Trudeau could lighten the work loads of cabinet ministers who currently oversee more than one portfolio

Group urges Canada to help Holocaust denier on trial in Germany

They’re concerned about Canada’s apparent unwillingness to come to the aid of Monika Schaefer

MGM sues Vegas mass shooting victims, argues it isn’t liable

The company argues it has “no liability of any kind” to survivors or families of slain victims

Usain Bolt to make run at pro soccer in Australia

Olympic sprint great has long expressed his love of the game

Duchess of Sussex wears dress by Calgary’s Nonie to Mandela exhibition

Nonie is believed to be the first Canadian based ready-to-wear designer for the duchess

Most Read