LETTER: Reader questions Deacon’s column about God

A Ponoka News read questions a Deacon’s column in the Nov. 14 edition of the paper

Dear Editor,

I write in response to Deacon Comeau’s Nov. 14 column entitled Reasons why I believe in God. Deacon Comeau gets some important facts wrong. Therefore, I offer my reasons why I don’t believe in god, following Deacon Comeau’s order.

First, I don’t believe in god because there is no evidence that our universe is the product of what Comeau calls a “ masterful design of an all knowing God”. In fact, modern sciences find that the natural world is the product of natural forces that we can observe, measure and understand. There are many natural mysteries, to be sure, but the fact that we don’t understand everything is not evidence for god’s existence.

Second, I don’t believe in god because there is no evidence for a soul or spirit that lives beyond our death. We know that the brain is the source of all our thoughts and feelings. When the brain dies, we die. There certainly is much more to life in addition to living and dying but we don’t need to posit an imaginary soul to find meaning and purpose.

I don’t believe in god because there is no extra-biblical evidence to confirm most of the stories found in the Bible. Deacon Comeau misrepresents historical truth when he claims that, “the life of Jesus [is] as factual and historical as…Alexander the Great and Julius Caesar.” The existence of Jesus is historically in doubt and currently stands as mere myth.

Read More: Ponoka Deacon speaks about belief in God

I don’t believe in god because of what Comeau calls the, “inherent goodness of humanity.” He and I agree on this one – humanity is inherently good. We don’t need an unseen god to be good. Every bit of goodness in the world comes from human action, not an invisible god who responds (or not) to magic words and begging.

Finally, I don’t believe in god because life is wonderful and precious without pretending that a sky-god is up there watching over us. My existence holds plenty of purpose without god. Loving my wife and children, serving my community, continuing to grow and learn while seeking truth and justice are just some of the things I do without god.

Deacon Comeau’s arguments don’t hold water because they are based on faith, not facts and a religious hubris that leaves billions of us out in the cold (or down in the heat, I guess).

Scott Lewis

Get local stories you won't find anywhere else right to your inbox.
Sign up here

Just Posted

1 in 7 Albertans have been tested for COVID-19

56 additional cases Thursday, 1,107 active cases remain in the province

Seven vying to lead ECN

Challengers to incumbent include NGCI president

Two females arrested for carjacking in Leduc; sword and bear spray used as weapon

Wetaskiwin and Maskwacis female arrested for carjacking.

94 new cases of COVID-19 in Alberta on Wednesday, two more deaths

1,146 active cases with 9,891 recovered cases

COVID-19: One more death reported in central zone

Number of active cases has decreased by more than 200 since last week

Protestors for Indigenous Lives Matter gather in Wetaskiwin

Protestors gathered along 56 St Wetaskiwin, Alta. August 4, 2020 for Indigenous Lives Matter.

Sylvan Lake man’s documentary getting limited run in Alberta theatres

Scott McDermott’s documentary will be in 14 theatres, including Sylvan Lake and Wetaskiwin

Other communities can learn from Sexsmith: AUMA president

Alberta Urban Municipalities Association is an advocacy group for urban municipalities

Proposed oil and gas assessment changes could have big impact on municipal revenues

Croup representing urban municipalities is concerned about the outcome

‘Do our lives count for less?’: COVID-19 exposes cracks in disability aid

In July, Parliament approved a $600 payment for people with disabilities facing additional expenses during COVID-19

Alberta man’s body recovered from Okanagan Lake after five-day search

‘The depth of the water, as well as the topography of the lake, made the recovery of the deceased very challenging’ - RCMP

Feds look to finalize deal with airlines amid contact tracing concerns

Feds look to finalize deal with airlines amid contact tracing concerns

Dwindling B.C. bamboo supply leaves Calgary Zoo biologists worried about pandas

Zoo has been trying to send pandas back to China since May

Booking.com cuts workforce by thousands as travel atrophies

Booking.com cuts workforce by thousands as travel atrophies

Most Read