Response to God in Ft. Mac fire

Readers responds to recent letter about God and world events.

Dear Editor,

I write in response to the May 25 edition wherein Mr. Brad Overeem asks “Where is God in the fire?”

He asks and attempts to answer the question that fundamentalist Christians can’t get around, namely, why does a loving god allow so much suffering. (In this case, where is god in the Ft. McMurray fire?)

As an atheist, I am interested in this discussion as I believe the question is central to my contention that there is no god. Mr. Overeem’s answer seems to be twofold. One, God is in the firefighters, god is in the kindness of strangers and so on. The other is that we know god loves us because the Bible says so. Mr. Overeem cites plenty of verses to this “prove” this.

What if I believed in some other myth (instead of the Christian one)?

Let us say I believe in the wonder working power of Santa Claus and I tell you that Santa Claus is in the caring people and brave first responders who worked so hard in Fort McMurray. Surely, that is not proof that Santa Claus is there helping even though we don’t see him. Or what if I tried to convince you that Santa Clause loves and cares for us even though our homes are burning to the ground, and all you have to do is look at various quotes from whatever children’s bedtime story I may produce?

Mr. Overeem may be comforted by his woolly-headed rationalizations about god. But whether we pretend that Zeus, Santa Claus or Jesus is helping us in a crisis is just silly.

Scott Lewis

Ponoka

 

Get local stories you won't find anywhere else right to your inbox.
Sign up here

Just Posted

Medical examiner: Floyd’s heart stopped while restrained

Medical examiner: Floyd’s heart stopped while restrained

More provinces moving to further loosen COVID-19 restrictions

More provinces moving to further loosen COVID-19 restrictions

WCPS, STAR Catholic raise busing fees

Both school divisions hike fees to compensate for budget changes

$2 raise for some health care workers in Alberta over a month late

Delay isn’t from Alberta Health, spokesperson confirms

‘Hate just hides’: Biden vows to take on systematic racism

‘Hate just hides’: Biden vows to take on systematic racism

On the spot where George Floyd died, his brother urges calm

On the spot where George Floyd died, his brother urges calm

Trump threatens military force against protesters nationwide

Trump threatens military force against protesters nationwide

Raptors guard VanVleet says people ‘fed up’ with racism and discrimination

Raptors guard VanVleet says people ‘fed up’ with racism and discrimination

Canada’s Davies helps Bayern top Fortuna 5-0 to take 10-point Bundesliga lead

Canada’s Davies helps Bayern top Fortuna 5-0 to take 10-point Bundesliga lead

Canada’s Olympic, Paralympic athletes get $5 million upon return to sport

Canada’s Olympic, Paralympic athletes get $5 million upon return to sport

NHL plans to test players for COVID-19 daily if games resume

NHL plans to test players for COVID-19 daily if games resume

Ottawa 67’s head coach Andre Tourigny named CHL coach of the year

Ottawa 67’s head coach Andre Tourigny named CHL coach of the year

Most Read